You Can Be Right on NVDA Tonight and Still Lose Money

The cliff in the chain
Look at implied volatility on the at-the-money NVDA options this morning (stock around $155.50):- Nov 18 expiry: 138%
- Nov 20: 112%
- Nov 27: 79%
- Dec 4: 71%
Right on Nvidia. Still red.
Let’s make it real. Say you buy the Nov 20 $155 call this morning at the $7.55 ask. You’re bullish. You’re betting on a pop. I ran it through Black-Scholes, assuming IV drops to about 57% after the print. That’s the “normal” vol the chain is pricing for the week after Thanksgiving, so it’s a fair guess, not a promise. Here’s what that call is worth Wednesday morning:- Stock flat: about $3.05. You’re down ~60%.
- Stock up 3%: about $6.14. You were RIGHT and you’re still down ~19%.
- Stock up ~4.2%: you finally break even.
- Stock up 8%: about $13.08. Now you’re making real money, up ~73%.

Does NVDA usually move that much?
I pulled NVDA’s last 12 earnings reactions, close on report day to close the next day. 8 of 12 moved less than the ±8.1% the options are pricing today. The average move was about 5.6%. The median was about 4.4%. The 4 that beat it? Feb ’24 (+16.4%), May ’24 (+9.3%), Feb ’25 (-8.5%) and Aug ’26 (+8.7%). Big moves happen. They just don’t happen as often as the price tag suggests.
The bull case for buying options anyway
Look, a third of the time NVDA has blown past the implied move. If you get one of those, a long call or put can double. And this setup isn’t sleepy: the stock’s down about 35% from its $239 high and sitting way under its 200-day (around $204). A stock that beat up can rip hard on a good number. If you’re going to play, size it like you’re fine losing every dollar of it. Because the math says you often will.The bear case (for the option buyer)
You need a big move just to break even, and history says you usually don’t get it. You can nail the direction, watch the stock gap your way, and still open your account to red. That’s the trade that makes people quit options. And the flip side isn’t free money either. Selling premium into earnings looks great until the one night the stock moves 16%. That’s how accounts blow up.What I’d actually do
- Know your breakeven before you click buy. Not the strike. The move the stock needs by the time you sell.
- If you must play the print, spread it. A debit spread sells some of that juiced premium back, so the crush hurts you less. We broke that down here: Trading Earnings With Debit Spreads.
- Or just wait. The cleanest trade is often tomorrow, after the crush, when options are cheap again and the chart tells you which way the market voted.
Keep reading
- NVDA Earnings: Options Are Pricing a ~$17 Move. Is That Too Much?
- NVDA Just Broke Its 52-Week Low. Options Are Paying Up for Fear.
- Chip Stocks Are Down 30%. History Says It’s a Coin Flip From Here.
Lesson 73 of 75 in the free Options Trading Course.
← Previous: Put Ratio Backspread: How to Trade Cheap Crash Protection
Next: Jade Lizard Options Strategy: Complete Step-by-Step Guide →


